Connect with us
Maduka University Advert

Politics

2027: Gang Up Against Tinubu Tickens as Ex Buhari’s Ministers Move To Dump APC For SDP

Published

on

Maduka University
There are strong indications that some former ministers of ex-President Muhammadu Buhari will move en masse to the Social Democratic Party.

A senator in the ninth Assembly, who spoke on condition of anonymity, said at least 10 former members of the Buhari cabinet were moving to the SDP.

“What they’re waiting for is the finalisation of the party structure in their respective states,” the source said.

Our correspondents gathered that leading Buhari’s loyalists in the defections are the former National Chairman of the All Progressives Congress, Abdullahi Adamu; ex-Attorney General of the Federation and Minister of Justice, Abubakar Malami; and former Senate President, Ahmed Lawan.

El-Rufai makes first move

Advertisement

One of Buhari’s loyalists and former governor of Kaduna State, Mallam Nasir El-Rufai, on Monday, defected to the SDP, citing a growing misalignment between his personal values and the current direction of the APC as the primary reason for his decision.

“Developments in the last two years confirm that those who currently control and run the APC do not desire to acknowledge, much less address, the party’s unhealthy situation.

“I have raised concerns in private and, more recently, in public regarding the party’s capricious trajectory. Therefore, at this point in my political journey, I have come to the conclusion that I must seek another political platform to pursue the progressive values I cherish,” he said.

El-Rufai, who is a vocal critic of President Bola Tinubu’s administration, disclosed on Wednesday that he sought Buhari’s approval before leaving the APC.

“I left the APC with his (Buhari’s) full knowledge. I visited him on a Friday and informed him of my decision to leave the party because I involve and consult with him on all my matters.

Advertisement

“I have those I consult with in everything I do. I inform them of anything I intend to do, and when they demand that I keep off, I do. My first godfather is Muhammadu Buhari.

“For the rest, I will not mention them because if I do, they’ll be pressured,” El-Rufai told the BBC Hausa service in an interview.

CPC bloc to work against Tinubu

El-Rufai’s defection and Buhari’s purported approval opened a floodgate of defections as some other members of the APC in the North, especially those of CPC extraction, have also been dumping the party.

Buhari, El-Rufai, Malami, and Lawan were leaders of the Congress for Progress Change until the party joined the Action Congress of Nigeria, a part of the All Progressives Grand Alliance, and members of the New Peoples Democratic Party to form the APC in 2013.

Advertisement

The former Kaduna governor’s statement also revealed the long-talked-about coalition involving some aggrieved leaders of the APC.

Following El-Rufai’s defection, a chieftain of the APC, Ahmad Kaita, who is a former senator, and member of the House of Representatives from Katsina, also joined the SDP.

Kaita is also a former member of the CPC.

Similarly, former Kaduna State commissioners for Agriculture, Ibrahim Hussaini; Justice, Aisha Dikko; Health, Amina Baloni; and Education, Halima Lawal; as well as former Head of Service, Hajiya Bari’atu Mohammed, also dumped the APC for the SDP.

Also, the Campaign Secretary of the APC in Gombe State during the 2015 general elections, Adamu Modibbo, has left the party. Modibbo is now the chairman of the SDP in the state.

Advertisement

A former Publicity Secretary of the APC in Borno State, Abdulaziz Galadima, while confirming his defection to the SDP to our correspondent, said he left the party because it deviated from the principles and ideology on which it was founded.

Galadima also confirmed that many original CPC members would leave the APC for “SDP or another party.”

Other politicians leaving

Efforts to reach Malami for comments on the matter failed as the SAN neither answered calls nor responded to messages sent to his mobile phone.

However, one of his closest aides confirmed his involvement in the coalition move.

Advertisement

The aide, who spoke on condition of anonymity, said, “It is not about ousting Tinubu in 2027 but about our conviction that we have better and more credible constitutional alternatives to offer Nigerians in governance, particularly with regard to institutionalising a human-centred approach to governance.

“We collectively abhor the prevailing order in which governance is commercialised to the detriment of Nigerians and their welfare. It seems to be a marriage of tendencies that cut across the existing political parties with high-profile politicians from PDP, defunct CPC, ACN and APC among others.

“In personality sense, those involved across the geographical zones include serving and former governors and senators, former ministers, and past and present party officials.”

The highly credible source mentioned former governors of Rivers, Imo, Cross Rivers, Sokoto and Osun states, Rotimi Amaechi, Emeka Ihedioha, Liyel Imoke, Aminu Tambuwal and Rauf Aregbesola, respectively, as part of the stakeholders in the coalition movement.

A former Senate President, David Mark; ex-national chairman of APC, Chief John Odigie-Oyegun; a former Buhari’s Minister of State for Education, Emeka Nwajiuba, and the senator representing Borno South, Ali Ndume, among others, were also involved in the coalition.

Advertisement

A chieftain of the APC in Imo State confirmed that the CPC extraction in the APC had concluded plans to leave the party for a coalition.

“That some ministers who served under Buhari are leaving or will leave the APC is confirmed. However, they may not join the SDP, but I know they are part of the coalition movement,” said the chieftain, who spoke on condition of anonymity.

According to him, no fewer than 10 ministers and many senators in the ninth National Assembly were leaving the APC.

He said, “President Tinubu has mismanaged the success of our party, and it is painful that things are going awry every day. APC bigwigs, both in the North and South, are not happy, and the President doesn’t care. You don’t grow by reducing in size. The APC is reducing in size.

“The CPC bloc of the party has also been leaving. You will agree with me that the CPC is a strong bloc in the APC, and if it is gone, I doubt if the APC will remain the same.

Advertisement

“Those leaving the APC are foundation members who have genuine followers. Apart from El-Rufai, other former governors are also involved in the political movement. These are not paperweight politicians.”

Similarly, a former Minister of Sports and Youth Development, Solomon Lalong, in an interview with Saturday PUNCH, said he was aware that many Nigerians, including former ministers, were involved in some political discussions.

Lalong, who left the APC for the SDP in 2022, said, “We are in discussions with many people across the country, including former ministers and senators. But because it is at the level of discussion, I will have to protect their identities.

“However, I can assure you that, from what is going on, a large number of the political class from across the political parties in Nigeria are coming together to have a common front.

“This problem Tinubu found himself in is self-inflicted. It is caused by his ego. He is an egoistic personality who sees himself as an emperor. He thinks he has conquered Nigeria. But I’m telling you that unless he changes his method of governance, we will soon know who Nigerians are.”

Advertisement

Lalong also accused President Tinubu of not treating Buhari fairly.

“The two of them aligned in 2014 to form the APC, which won the election. Buhari conceded the vice president to Tinubu and five other ministers, and he supported his presidential ambition.

“Currently, Tinubu cannot mention a single special adviser he considered for Buhari in his administration. The President is not treating Buhari fairly,” he added.

Aregbesola’s media adviser, Sola Fasure, declined to comment on the purported plan by the former Minister of Interior to join the SDP.

“We will talk about our political movement at the right time,” he said.

Advertisement

But one of Aregbesola’s loyalists, who spoke to Saturday PUNCH on condition of anonymity, said the former governor had been invited to join the SDP.

According to the insider, Aregbesola is part of a political movement involving some of his colleagues from the Buhari administration and other prominent politicians in the country.

He said, “I can’t confirm whether it is the SDP we are joining, but I know there is an ongoing political movement. Some ministers and former APC officials are involved.

“The movement is even bigger than any single political party. From my understanding, even if we join the SDP, the African Democratic Congress, or any other party, it will only serve as a structure. Eventually, all these smaller parties will collapse into a coalition in 2027. A coalition is the main game.”

Aregbesola’s group, Omoluabi Progressives, left the APC a few months ago, citing ostracism, suspension, and expulsion of members without fair hearing, as well as the perceived neglect and marginalisation of the group within the APC structure.

Advertisement

When contacted, Buhari’s media aide, Garba Shehu, said he would have to reach the former president before commenting on the reported defection plan of his ministers.

But Buhari has reiterated that he is a loyal member of the APC and would like to be addressed as such.

Source: PUNCH

Advertisement
Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Politics

Mob Attacks Tinubu’s Praise Singer Rarara at Abuja Mosque

Published

on

Maduka University

Hausa musician and prominent All Progressives Congress (APC) supporter, Dauda Kahutu, popularly known as Rarara, was on Friday attacked by a mob at the National Mosque in Abuja.

The attack, which reportedly occurred shortly after he arrived at the mosque for Friday prayers, has sparked condemnation from political figures who warned against political intolerance and retaliatory violence.

Rarara is known for producing praise songs for President Bola Tinubu and other APC politicians.

A video of the incident showed a crowd surrounding and assaulting a man, while security operatives struggled to control the situation.

His clothes were reportedly torn during the attack before some worshippers intervened and rescued him.

Advertisement

He was also seen wearing a cap bearing Tinubu’s insignia before reportedly removing it at some point during the incident.

Former factional presidential candidate of the Labour Party, Kennedy Ahanotu, condemned the assault, describing it as a disturbing development, particularly because it occurred in a place of worship.

In a statement issued in Abuja on Saturday, Ahanotu said the incident posed a threat to political tolerance, national unity and the fundamental rights of citizens, irrespective of their political affiliations.

He maintained that supporting Tinubu, belonging to the APC or expressing one’s political convictions was a democratic right that should not attract violence or intimidation.

Ahanotu, however, cautioned APC supporters against resorting to retaliation, urging them to pursue justice through lawful and democratic means.

Advertisement

He called on the Inspector-General of Police, the FCT Police Command and other security agencies to investigate the incident, identify those responsible and ensure they were brought to justice.

He also urged the government to strengthen security for political actors, campaign supporters and ordinary citizens ahead of the 2027 general elections.

Similarly, former media aide to ex-Vice President Atiku Abubakar, Paul Ibe, condemned the attack, questioning the ability of security agencies to protect Nigerians despite the heavy security deployment at the National Mosque during Friday prayers.

Ibe observed that worshippers were still exposed to violence despite the presence of security operatives and the reported cordoning off of adjoining roads.

He insisted that political differences should never become a justification for assaulting anyone.

Advertisement

He further questioned what confidence ordinary Nigerians could have in their safety if worshippers could not be protected in an environment with such a heavy security presence.

Ibe also said Rarara’s support for Tinubu was his democratic right and should not make him a target of violence, although he argued that the President’s political standing was increasingly becoming a liability to the singer.

The attack came six days after some worshippers reportedly booed President Tinubu and threw objects at his convoy following Friday prayers at the Shehu Shagari Central Mosque in the Garki area of Abuja.

The incident triggered a security response, with some worshippers reportedly arrested. Tinubu subsequently directed that those arrested be released.

Rarara is widely known for producing songs in support of the APC and Tinubu, including Omologo, which featured prominently at the President’s campaign rallies. He also performed the song for Tinubu during an official visit to Katsina State.

Advertisement
Continue Reading

Politics

Onitsha Stands Still for Obi as He Urges Nigerians to Protect Votes in 2027

Published

on

Maduka University

Pledges massive investment in education, says January 16 will determine Nigeria’s future

By Okey Maduforo, Awka

Commercial activities were temporarily disrupted in Onitsha, Anambra State, on Friday as thousands of supporters and residents trooped out to welcome the presidential candidate of the Nigeria Democratic Congress (NDC), Mr Peter Obi, during his visit to the commercial city.

Obi, who was received by an enthusiastic crowd, called on Nigerians to make a personal sacrifice on January 16, 2027, by ensuring that their votes were protected from the polling units until the final announcement of election results.

The former Anambra State governor made the appeal during a town hall meeting with members of the public at All Saints Anglican Cathedral, Onitsha.

Advertisement

He urged voters not to abandon their polling units after casting their ballots but to remain vigilant and monitor the entire electoral process to prevent manipulation.

“Go with your stool, cast your vote. Sit down, wait, monitor and guard your vote.

“Follow it, till it’s counted, recorded and announced because the future of our country is in our hands,” Obi said.

He described the election as an opportunity for Nigerians to determine the future of the country through democratic participation, stressing that citizens must be prepared to sacrifice one day to secure a better Nigeria.

Obi also reiterated his commitment to making education a major priority if elected president, promising massive and measurable investment in the sector.

Advertisement

Earlier, he visited Christ the King College (CKC), Onitsha, his alma mater, where he inspected a teachers’ residential building being constructed through his support and that of other benefactors.

The building, which was already at the painting stage, is expected to provide comfortable accommodation for teachers and other personnel of the institution.

Obi said the project was part of efforts to restore the dignity of education and provide teachers with an enabling environment to discharge their responsibilities.

“I’m here to inspect the teachers’ house at CKC. This is my alma mater, and we are doing this to secure the pride of education and also give teachers the comfort they need to be able to impart education on our children.

“I take time to come here and support what they do from time to time. I and others built this teachers’ house for the school. Education to me remains the tool for development,” he said.

Advertisement

He added that if given the opportunity to lead Nigeria, his administration would make substantial investments in education, insisting that the impact would be visible and measurable.

“It is one investment that if I have the opportunity to serve Nigeria, everybody will visibly and measurably see our investment in education.

“This is because the more you educate the society, the more developed the society becomes. When I was governor in Anambra State, I visited every school and contributed to their turnaround because I believe in education,” he said.

He further stressed the need to provide comfortable working and living conditions for teachers, security personnel and other workers in educational institutions.

Also speaking, Senator Victor Umeh, the NDC senatorial candidate for Anambra Central, described Obi as the most suitable candidate for the 2027 presidential election.

Advertisement

Umeh said Nigerians across the country were clamouring for Obi’s presidency, urging the South-East to ensure that no vote was lost during the election.

“Nigerians nationwide are clamouring for Mr Peter Obi’s presidency, and I call on the South-East not to allow any single vote to be lost. We are giving him 100 per cent votes,” he said.

Similarly, activist Madam Aisha Yusuf declared that Nigerians would no longer tolerate electoral manipulation.

“I want to say it again, no man or woman will rig our election ever again,” she said.

The NDC senatorial candidate for Anambra South, Chief Ebuka Onunkwo, described the forthcoming general election as a litmus test for Nigeria’s progress.

Advertisement

He expressed confidence that the party would secure victory in Anambra South, saying residents of the district had resolved to support the NDC.

Before Obi’s arrival at the town hall venue, a roadshow was held across major parts of Onitsha, beginning from the Bridge Head area of the First Niger Bridge and moving through Ochanja Roundabout, Onitsha Main Market, Iweka Road and other strategic locations.

Obi rode in a motorcade, waving to supporters, traders, residents and party loyalists who lined the streets to welcome him.

The roadshow, which attracted a massive turnout, reportedly forced several traders to temporarily close their shops as they joined the procession in solidarity with the NDC presidential candidate.

The crowd and accompanying motorcade caused heavy traffic congestion around major commercial routes, particularly Awka Road, prompting motorists and commuters heading towards Onitsha Main Market to seek alternative routes.

Advertisement

Security operatives were deployed across the affected areas to manage traffic, control the crowd and maintain order.

The visit formed part of the NDC presidential candidate’s nationwide engagements ahead of the 2027 general election.

Continue Reading

Politics

2027: Tinubu May Win Only Two States If Election Is Free, Fair – Baba-Ahmed

Published

on

Maduka University

The National Chairman of the Peoples Redemption Party (PRP), Dr Hakeem Baba-Ahmed, has predicted that President Bola Tinubu could win no more than two states in the 2027 presidential election if the exercise is free, fair and credible.
Baba-Ahmed said growing dissatisfaction with the Tinubu administration, particularly over the economy and insecurity, could cost the ruling All Progressives Congress (APC) its hold on power.
Speaking in an interview with ARISE NEWS on Friday, the PRP chairman accused the administration of prioritising political survival over addressing the country’s economic and security challenges.
He said Nigerians were increasingly frustrated by rising living costs, insecurity and the difficulties confronting households across the country.
“If the elections are free and fair, President Tinubu, I repeat, will not win this election. Nigerians as a whole, not just Northwest, will reject him because he has not performed anywhere near what they expected.
“The Tinubu administration was more interested in just being in power than actually fixing problems in the country,” he said.
Baba-Ahmed explained that his assessment was based on his party’s direct engagement with ordinary Nigerians and their experiences under the current administration.
“We don’t just assume things. We mix with them. We don’t give them money. We don’t have the money that APC has to give them. So, we engage with them. We follow their lives. We follow their opinions. We are in touch with their sentiments,” he stated.
Clarifying his earlier prediction, the PRP chairman said his assessment was nationwide and not limited to the North-West or North-East.
“I said if the elections are credible, free and fair in 2027, President Tinubu is unlikely to win more than two states. I didn’t even say anything about the Northwest. I said in the country,” he added.
On efforts to build a united opposition ahead of the 2027 general election, Baba-Ahmed said the PRP had participated in coalition discussions from the beginning, describing the initiative as an attempt to provide Nigerians with a credible alternative to the APC.
“Our party has been part of the coalition from day one and we’re very proud of the role we have played. We have participated in all of it,” he said.
He identified the Social Democratic Party (SDP), PRP, Peoples Democratic Party (PDP), Allied Peoples Movement (APM), African Democratic Congress (ADC) and Nigeria Democratic Congress (NDC) as parties involved in the discussions.
He added that more political parties were expected to join the coalition before the end of November.
According to Baba-Ahmed, the coalition has identified two major objectives, including working with Nigerians to remove the APC from power.
“We have identified two fundamentals that we have to achieve. One is to work with Nigerians to make sure that we remove the APC administration from the neck of Nigerians. It is absolutely necessary that this administration does not come back,” he said.
He expressed confidence that the opposition could defeat the ruling party if it presented a credible alternative to Nigerians.
“We are providing Nigerians a credible option to the APC, the most credible option to the APC. And we have a very comfortable expectation that we will win this election because Nigerians will reject from top to bottom. They will reject APC,” he added.
The PRP chairman also expressed concern over increasing political violence and what he described as restrictions on opposition parties’ ability to campaign freely.
He alleged that opposition parties were facing both physical attacks and subtle forms of intimidation, including difficulties accessing public spaces and securing locations for campaign activities.
“The escalating incidences of violence. Violence has now become a major factor in this politics. Not just overt violence, people beating opponents, people disrupting rallies and killing people. But the violence that is subtle.
“The antics of the APC closing the campaigning space for the opposition. You cannot mount billboards, you can’t have access to places to campaign,” he said.
Baba-Ahmed also dismissed suggestions that northerners would be hypocritical if they withdrew their support for Tinubu after voting for him in the 2023 presidential election.
He argued that voters had the democratic right to change their political preferences based on their assessment of the president’s performance.
“If the north elected Tinubu in 2023, it was the rights of northerners who felt that Tinubu was a better candidate than Obi and Atiku. And they have the same right now to reject Tinubu. There’s nothing hypocritical about this. That is what politics is all about,” he said.
He attributed growing discontent in the North to worsening insecurity and the rising cost of living, which he said had made it increasingly difficult for families to meet basic needs.
“There are towns, there are states where huge numbers, huge parts of the states in the north are under bandits or are vulnerable to bandit attack at any minute. Cost of living is impossible. You can’t pay school fees. You can’t take your children to the hospital. You can’t feed your family,” he stated.
The PRP chairman further accused the Tinubu administration of worsening the living conditions of Nigerians.
“Tinubu’s administration has destroyed lives and has made lives wretched. And this is why Nigerians are angry with him,” he added.
Defending his decision to criticise the president despite previously serving in his administration as Special Adviser on Political Matters, Baba-Ahmed said he left because he became convinced that the government was not sufficiently committed to governance.
“I left the administration because I saw no evidence that President Tinubu’s administration was serious about governance,” he said.
He explained that he had initially been part of the administration but left about a year to a year and a half after it began because of concerns about its direction.
He also faulted the government’s presentation of economic statistics, arguing that official figures did not reflect the hardship experienced by ordinary Nigerians.
“Rolling out statistics and figures and telling Nigerians we’re doing well, when in fact, life was becoming more and more impossible to deal with,” he said.
Baba-Ahmed further criticised the state of the country inherited by Tinubu from his predecessor, former President Muhammadu Buhari, arguing that the current administration had worsened an already difficult situation.
“President Buhari handed over to Tinubu a country in a mess. And President Tinubu took it and made it considerably worse,” he stated.
Nigeria is expected to hold its next general election in 2027, with opposition parties facing the challenge of building a united front against the ruling APC.
The coalition discussions involving the PRP, ADC, PDP, SDP, APM and NDC reflect ongoing efforts by opposition leaders to coordinate their political activities and improve their chances of defeating the ruling party.
In the 2023 presidential election, Tinubu emerged victorious on the APC platform, while Atiku Abubakar contested for the PDP, Peter Obi for the Labour Party and Rabiu Kwankwaso for the New Nigeria Peoples Party (NNPP).

Continue Reading

Politics

‘Bamayi’ Chant Sparks Violence As Suspected Mob Attack APC Convoy, 5 buses destroyed

Published

on

Maduka University

An APC campaign convoy in Gombe State has reportedly come under attack by suspected political thugs following the chanting of an anti-party slogan, “Bamayi”, in Kwarge community, Balanga Local Government Area.

The incident, which occurred at about 5pm on Wednesday, reportedly left five campaign buses damaged and several party supporters injured.

The convoy was travelling from Cham to Bambam as part of the All Progressives Congress (APC) campaign tour of Balanga South ahead of the 2027 general elections when the incident occurred.

According to eyewitness accounts, trouble started when some youths emerged from their homes and began chanting “Bamayi” as the campaign convoy approached the community.

The expression, which is used locally to signify rejection, disagreement or lack of support, reportedly angered some youths accompanying the campaign team, resulting in a confrontation.

Advertisement

An eyewitness, who spoke on condition of anonymity, said the situation quickly deteriorated as more youths joined the protest.

The source said the confrontation later escalated into an attack on the convoy, with some of the alleged attackers reportedly armed with clubs and cutlasses.

Five Gombe Line buses conveying APC supporters were said to have been damaged, while several supporters sustained injuries.

However, no death was recorded.

The circumstances surrounding the violence and the identities of those responsible remained unclear as of the time of filing this report.

Advertisement

The incident occurred on the second day of the APC campaign tour of Balanga, following the official flag-off of the party’s campaign at Bajoga, headquarters of Funakaye Local Government Area, on Saturday.

Meanwhile, Governor Muhammadu Inuwa Yahaya had led APC candidates and party leaders on visits to the palaces of the Polo of Daadiya, Abdulkadir-Abubakar Galadima, and the Ndu of Cham, James Chachi, as part of efforts to seek traditional support ahead of the elections.

The campaign team also visited Jessu-Nyuwar, Kindiyo, Mwona and Bambam communities for the commissioning of Local Council Development Areas.

Speaking during the campaign, Yahaya expressed confidence in the party’s electoral prospects, saying Gombe State would witness greater development with the calibre of candidates presented by the APC.

The APC Deputy Chairman, Baba Abuja, also urged residents of Nyuwar to support the party in the forthcoming elections.

Advertisement

Similarly, the APC candidate for Balanga South State Constituency, Melton Yahaya, commended the electorate and expressed confidence in the party’s campaign.

Continue Reading

Politics

I’m not campaigning against Tinubu, Mbah – APC Chieftain Dr Odumegwu Debunks Allegation

Published

on

Maduka University

A Chieftain of the All Progressives Congress (APC), Dr Ejikeme Odumegwu (Esq), has debunked the falsehood in an online social media post alleging that he is campaigning against the President of the Federal Republic of Nigeria, His Excellency Asiwaju Ahmed Tinubu, and Gov. Peter Ndubisi Mbah, the Executive Governor of Enugu State.

Odumegwu, who is the Owelle of Nsukka, made this known in a statement he signed and issued on Thursday in Enugu.

He described the trending social media post, which is a total falsehood, as a cheap blackmail by the opposition.

Odumegwu, who was the former Senior Special Assistant to the Executive Governor of Enugu State, noted that he had always pointed out the difficulty in securing a victory for Hon. Dennis Agbo, member representing Igboeze North/Udenu Federal Constituency.

According to him, this is owing to his (Dennis Agbo) impunity and nonchalant attitude towards his constituents.

Advertisement

Odumegwu, who is the current National Coordinator of Mass Mobilisation For Asiwaju Tinubu, allegedly reiterated that he won the APC Primary for House of Representatives against Agbo.

“I shall continue to campaign for President Tinubu/Gov. Mbah and will continue to challenge the opposition with facts and figures on these leaders verifiable performance.

“But for Dennis Agbo, at least the entire South-East owe our brother Peter Obi some sacrificial Lambs which obviously Dennis Agbo is one. He won’t enjoy my fruit of labour with total ignominy and have my support and blessings.

“If I am doubted, let me be involved in all the APC Presidential and Governorship active campaign exercises,” Odumegwu, who is the Founder/Coordinator of CRUSADE FOR PETER MBAH, said.

Advertisement
Continue Reading
Advertisement

Trending